Three years on: Reflecting on the UPC’s first years
Few developments have reshaped the European patent landscape in recent years as significantly as the launch of the Unified Patent Court (UPC) in 2023, which introduced a new approach to patent protection and enforcement across participating European states.
Three years on, the Court is no longer a new institution finding its feet. With a growing body of case law and increasing numbers of filings, the UPC has established itself as a central forum for patent litigation in Europe.
Paul Clarkson, Partner and British & European Patent Attorney at NLO, spoke with Florence Butin, President of the Court of First Instance, about the UPC’s development so far, the lessons learned along the way and what the future holds for the Court.
Florence Butin
President of the Court of First Instance, Unified Patent Court
Since the UPC opened its doors in 2023, it has become an established part of the European patent landscape. Looking back, has its development matched the expectations you had at the time?
Since the Court began its judicial activities, the number of cases it has received, and subsequent filing trends, have far exceeded our expectations and continue to do so. We first had to gain the trust of users, both those who brought the first cases before the Court and those who preferred to wait and observe how the system would work in practice. While it is not perfect in every respect, as is true of any new institution, I believe the UPC is now perceived as a well-established, sustainable and reliable court. The number of unitary patents granted by the European Patent Office (EPO) is an objective indication of that.
Considering the financial, logistical and managerial aspects, it is extremely important that we are able to mobilise the necessary resources and respond quickly when urgent needs are identified. During these three years of operation, the UPC has increased the working hours of almost all its judges and recruited additional judges, using the reserve list of available judges which was completed by way of new calls for interest. The Court began operations with less than 90 legally and technically qualified judges. Today, that number has increased to 135 across both instances. Of the 55 legally qualified judges, 37 are now employed by the Court on a full-time basis. An additional recruitment process is currently being considered.
If we look back and consider the challenging framework within which we started, as most of the judges had to combine their national duties with their fixed part-time position at the UPC, we succeeded in implementing these adjustments when they became necessary. The model was initially designed to be very flexible, but from an operational and human perspective, it was not always easy to work with.
Another urgent priority was the development and implementation of a completely new case management system, based on the experience gained during the Court's first year of operation. This was achieved without any negative impact on case processing.
I could give many other examples, but I think these developments, particularly those relating to our digital environment and the growth of our teams, provide a good illustration of the progress we have made.
One of the original ambitions of the UPC was to provide a more efficient and harmonised approach to patent litigation across Europe. To what extent do you feel that the UPC is already delivering on that ambition?
There are different aspects to consider here. As the UPC is a ‘Unified’ court common to 18 European countries, composed of experienced judges with significant backgrounds in patent litigation, the divisions initially issued decisions that reflected their own approaches, and some of those decisions were appealed. The Court of Appeal has now started to develop its case law on many procedural and substantial questions, including interpretation, claim construction, inventive step and competence, and its reasoning is adopted by the panels of the Court of First Instance. National courts may also take these decisions into account, just as they consider decisions issued in other countries. Regarding validity questions, the opposition divisions of the EPO and the Boards of Appeal are additional sources of case law.
In addition to the composition of the panels, which include one or two international judges, meaning judges who are not local to the division, and generally a technically qualified judge with no nationality requirement, there are many opportunities for judges to exchange views through, for example, trainings and conferences. So, I think the harmonisation process is already well underway. The growing body of appeal decisions is also contributing to greater legal certainty.
For businesses looking to protect and enforce their innovations in Europe, what do you see as the main advantages of the UPC today?
One of the primary goals of the UPC is to deliver decisions covering all participating European countries, allowing a patent to be enforced or revoked in a single action. This saves considerable resources for litigants and avoids potentially divergent decisions on infringement or validity by different national courts.
Another important advantage is the predictability of the proceedings. The front-loaded approach requires parties to present their cases early and comply with strict deadlines, unlike proceedings where deadlines for exchanging written submissions are set on a case-by-case basis. Although the one-year target for holding the final oral hearing can be adjusted flexibly and proportionately, taking all interests and the complexity of the case into account, it still gives an indication of how long proceedings are expected to last. This clarity is particularly important for companies developing their strategies and business plans in light of ongoing disputes.
The composition of the panels is also a key advantage. A technically qualified judge is automatically included when the validity of a patent is challenged. In infringement actions, a TQJ can also be appointed at the parties’ request or after the judge-rapporteur has consulted them. Their participation allows the judges to discuss all technical aspects of the case in depth during both the written and oral proceedings, including the final deliberations. Coming from a system where panels do not have this technical expertise, and where it can only be provided in exceptional circumstances by appointing a court expert, I wondered whether, and to what extent, this would influence the discussion. In my view, it certainly does, particularly at the oral hearing, where direct exchanges with the representatives are possible. This can lead to more lively, in-depth discussions focused on technical points.
The UPC was seen as an opportunity for Patent Attorneys to take a greater role. Do you have any observations about the contributions that we have made to the Court thus far?
European patent attorneys are increasingly involved as UPC representatives, both as members of mixed, multinational teams alongside lawyers and as lead representatives, particularly in revocation cases before the sections of the central division. The composition of these teams mirrors that of the Court’s panels, which include technically qualified judges.
Most of our technically qualified judges are also patent attorneys, working either in-house or in private practice alongside their judicial duties. Those who continue to work in private practice bring a valuable perspective to the Court’s discussions, complementing the experience of legally qualified judges. From seeing how this collaboration works and speaking to my technically qualified colleagues, I have found them very conscious of the importance of their role and keen to contribute to the UPC’s judicial work. I am impressed by their motivation and their ability to balance this work with their other commitments. These ‘on-call’ assignments require prior discussions about whether they have the capacity to take on a specific case, and within which timeframe. This exchange usually takes place with the President’s office when their appointment to a panel is being considered. The schedule is adjusted later with the judge-rapporteur.
Despite the concerns some observers initially raised about their impartiality and the potential difficulties arising from this, personally I was convinced from the outset that technically qualified judges would play a crucial role within the system, and this has proved to be the case. Of course, this requires appropriate measures are needed to prevent any potential conflicts of interest. In practice, technically qualified judges now routinely carry out conflict checks, and the results may be disclosed to the parties where this is considered warranted.
Technically qualified judges are also often involved in accelerated proceedings and are increasingly appointed to panels even before a counterclaim for revocation has been filed. Both legally and technically qualified judges greatly value this collaboration, and it has been further strengthened through regular exchanges and the adoption of best practices, which are discussed during our annual training sessions.
Since June 2023, we have expanded the initial pool of technically qualified judges through two additional recruitment rounds in response to the increasing number of cases in electricity and physics, which tend to be complex.
I would also like to highlight the contribution of other users of the Court – including patent attorneys – who can participate in UPC committees as observers. They have contributed a great deal to the development of our new case management system by sharing their experience and suggestions.
The numbers appear to prove that the UPC is an enormous success. As President of the Court of First Instance, do you have all of the means that you need to prevent it becoming a victim of its own success, in particular to adequately distribute the huge workload between the various divisions and seats?
My role is not the easiest in the system. The UPC was designed with local and regional divisions where parties can choose to bring their cases, as outlined in the Agreement and Rules of Procedure. If that choice results in ten cases being filed with one division and only one with another, the ‘permanent’ judges in the busier division must handle those ten cases, with different international judges joining them on the panels.
Under the current interpretation of the legal framework established by the UPCA, the President’s office cannot actively influence the distribution of cases between divisions, for example by reassigning them. Under Article 8 UPCA, the international judges serving as the second and/or third members of a panel are drawn from a pool that includes judges from the central, local and regional divisions. They can be assigned on a case-by-case or long-term basis where necessary for the efficient functioning of divisions with a high workload. When deciding on panel composition, we must consider language requirements, related cases filed within the same division or across several divisions, and, of course, the judges’ workloads. That workload, including travel time, must be shared as fairly as possible.
The workload of certain divisions, particularly the German divisions and, more recently, The Hague, which is handling a growing proportion of UPC cases, can be balanced to some extent by assigning judges from less busy divisions. However, this also involves travel time and practical constraints that should not be overlooked. These international or ‘travelling’ judges can also act as judge-rapporteur and make a greater contribution to case management in the busiest divisions.
Alongside distributing the workload, which is of course crucial, we must ensure that there are sufficient opportunities for judges across the Court of First Instance to exchange views and share experience. A model that draws a clear distinction between ‘permanent’ national judges and ‘travelling’ judges assigned from the pool should therefore be seen as a transitional arrangement, rather than a model for the future.
Another possibility is for the central division to play a greater role. It has not featured in the current discussions about the uneven distribution of cases because responsibility for cases within it is determined by IPC classification. Under Article 33 of the Agreement, however, cases may be brought before the central division where one or more defendants have their domicile or place of business outside the Contracting Member States. Local divisions may also refer a counterclaim for revocation, if not the whole case, to the central division where there are good reasons to do so. For example, the central division may be in a position to issue a quicker decision where other parties have brought parallel, standalone revocation actions. Within the central division, it is possible to adjust panel composition to reflect the workload of each section and the language requirements. A judge appointed to the Munich section may therefore be involved in a case filed at the Paris seat.
To conclude, I think that the UPC has sufficient resources to manage the consequences of its success, rather than simply grow. However, we need to address the uneven distribution of cases and ensure that the ongoing debate and reservations do not overshadow the very positive perception of the Court’s work, both in Europe and beyond.
Looking back over the Court's first three years, what have been some of the most important lessons learned?
One very important lesson early on was the need for a proper administrative framework in such a complex environment. This had been somewhat overlooked in the overall design and had to be addressed as we gained experience of running the Court. A good example is the creation of legal adviser and head of office posts for the two Presidents, who initially had to work under difficult conditions without this support. The Administrative Committee recently recognised how important these posts are by allowing judges to devote most of their time to these administrative duties while retaining a proportion of their judicial work.
We also learned that, although the divisions are spread across the UPC countries, they need to remain closely connected so that they are not perceived as ‘national UPC courts’. Exchanges between judges, and between clerks, reinforce the unified and international character of our institution. It is equally important that our premises, courtrooms and facilities develop consistently across the Court. This requires ongoing dialogue and cooperation with all participating Member States, which provide these local resources.
These are just a few examples of what we have learned so far, but personally, I am still learning every day.
The UPC agreement provides various mechanisms for reviewing the Rules of Procedure and the Agreement itself. Have these proven adequate, and what is the most important ‘adjustment’ that you have been able to implement so far?
The first important change to our legal framework was the amendment to the UPCA on 26 June 2023, following the UK’s withdrawal, to establish the Milan section of the central division and update the allocation of cases by IPC classification. This arose from the specific need to bring the Agreement into line with EU law. Article 87.1 UPCA provides for a broad consultation with users on how well and efficiently the current system works, after seven years or once 2,000 infringement cases have been decided. Based on the outcome of this consultation and the Court’s opinion, the Administrative Committee may decide to begin a revision process to improve the functioning of the UPC. Any such decision requires the necessary majority among the Contracting Member States.
The UPC Rules of Procedure can be amended by a decision of the Administrative Committee, based on a proposal from the Court and following consultation with the European Commission. Any amendments must remain consistent with the Agreement and its annexed Statute and cannot alter either. The Statute itself may be amended following a proposal from the Court or a Contracting Member State under Article 40.2 UPCA. This gives the Court considerable scope to propose changes, as important aspects of its structure and operation are set out in the Statute. This provision may also be relevant when revising the Rules of Procedure, to ensure that the two remain aligned. This revision process was initiated in September 2026, following consultation with organisations representing Court users and with all judges and clerks. The relevant provisions set no specific timetable, allowing the working group responsible to examine all proposals and their potential impact on other rules. Although there is no deadline for producing the consolidated version, the working group has scheduled monthly meetings and intends to submit it to the Administrative Committee as soon as possible.
How else do you see the UPC developing over the next few years?
Like any other young institution, we have a lot of areas to improve and projects to initiate.
We now have enough experience and perspective to really start harmonising our practices, and the revision of our Rules of Procedure will certainly help with this. We often discuss how the case is introduced at the start of the oral hearing, which may include the panel’s preliminary views on certain issues, but harmonisation can extend to many aspects of case management, such as the interim conference, the organisation of the final oral hearing and communication between representatives and the Court. New templates reflecting the ‘UPC judgment style’ we have adopted and the procedural orders issued since the Court began would also be helpful.
We also intend to develop an internship scheme, allowing the Court to welcome interns under the relevant national arrangements, in cooperation with national courts, judicial and legal training institutions, and universities.
Considering the recent appointments and opportunities for experienced judges to move from the CFI to the Court of Appeal, it will also be important to reflect on how we can facilitate the onboarding of newcomers. The Court’s working capacity must remain a priority, because its excellent start and success stem from the commitment of the judges and Registry, and from the quality of the decisions delivered. Additionally, the tight timelines prescribed by our Rules of Procedure present a constant challenge for all involved.
As our database and communication tools are currently under review, I expect that case law research will become easier, which is a long-awaited improvement.
Finally, it will be very interesting to see how the PMAC (Patent Mediation and Arbitration Centre) develops and how it interacts with the Court.